When religion prohibits consent and agency

I had an epiphany while crying in the ladies room two weeks ago after a triggering sermon. It’s something I’ve suspected for a while, and while this may be obvious to those who have left the faith, it’s a new revelation for me: the evangelicalism I’ve fallen into forbids me to think for myself.

I thought this when a well-intentioned church leader asked me what was wrong – I figured I might as well explain, because insisting “I’m fine” in between dry heaves is really not convincing. She listened intently while I gave a brief explanation of why healing stories are so hurtful to me, and seemed genuinely sad when I said I wasn’t too sure if I believed in an intervening god anymore. Had she stopped at “We just don’t understand God’s ways,” I’d have been fine – I think it’s a cop-out answer to give to a grieving person, but it’s nonetheless true. When the conversation shifted to “Did your father have a personal relationship with Jesus? Have you asked him to be your Savior?” I shut down. That wasn’t the talk I needed at all, but I guess that doesn’t matter if one is following a script, which was what the discussion started to feel like.

If I didn’t care at all about being polite, I’d have stood up and left. I’d have insisted more clearly that I didn’t want to pray in the bathroom with her because being put on the spot like that makes me immensely uncomfortable. But I sat there, complying, because of a voice in my head that insisted, She’s just trying to lead you back, you know. You have so much bitterness in your heart that you refuse to hand over to God – you can’t make decisions about what’s really best for you right now.

That same self-doubting voice was there during seminary, too: You have no right to shrug off those people who are telling you to forgive the guy who keeps harassing you for a date – you know forgiveness is the right choice, but you’re just bitter because he reminds you of your ex boyfriend.

And in college ministry: It doesn’t matter what your family dynamic looks like, or how they feel about religion. God is calling you to sit your parents down right now and share Jesus with them! You’re just afraid.

This bitterness and fear were the common denominators of all those self-doubting moments, I’ve realized. I can’t trust when my intuition is telling me to get out of a potentially dangerous (emotionally, that is) situation because my bitterness, my fear – my sin – has made it impossible for me to think straight.

What I never stopped and asked myself until now is, how do I know the judgment of my Christian peers isn’t clouded by their sin? Can anyone be trusted?

Autonomy, agency, and rights to my own body – the right to pull away from a stranger who insists on grabbing my arms to pray with her when I already refused – have been deemed “selfish” by many, if not most, of the church groups I’ve been part of over the last seven years. I know why this is: The heart is deceitful above all things (Jeremiah 17:9). I don’t know how many times I’ve heard that – but now I’m starting to think that the real deceit is when people who don’t know your situation very well think they know what’s good for you; when they think a dash of prayer and a sprinkle of Bible verses will suffice, and having been a Christian longer than I have automatically lends credibility even if they have never been in my shoes.

I am all for community and friends who can hold each other accountable. But friends have the advantage of earned intimacy in the struggles of your life; strangers do not. And every time I doubted my ability to know what is best for me was under the pressure of acquaintances who happened to attend the same church.

Advertisements

About Beth Caplin

Just an author, blogger, and editor working hard so my cats can have a better life.
This entry was posted in Theology and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to When religion prohibits consent and agency

  1. Crystal says:

    If it’s okay, I’d like to share something personal, in a nutshell. It was BECAUSE I was not allowed to question or to use my brain (although the Bible says to worship the Lord your God with your mind as the first great commandment) that I have left Christianity. I still long for a personal relationship with God, believe passionately in the power of prayer, and love theological discussions about the Bible, but that’s about it. I’m going back to the spiritual ideas I had as a preteen and teen – ideas involving alternative spiritualities. Perhaps they can help add spiritual richness to my life in a way traditional Christianity can’t, although I will emphasise that the parts of Christianity that I love have also enriched my life in ways other spiritualities never could. I know that they did when I was younger. Yet I’m still deeply aware of God’s love and as I grow more I hope to be aware of his presence as well.

    Now, I’m focused on making the world a better place. I’d love to contemplate, yet I am also aware I have a job to do. Is not social reform putting Jesus’ command into action to love your neighbour as yourself?

    Like

  2. Jan says:

    Don’t “should” on yourself, Beth.

    Like

  3. nessa3 says:

    I get you. I struggle with the shoulds, and put everyone first thats the christian thing to do…the counsellor Im seeing keeps trying to tell me I need to take care of myself and not worry what everyone else would think….have good boundaries….
    I left a church that it wasnt christain to have boundaries and protect yourself….if you were like christ nothing offended you.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I hear you. I’m coming out of Pentecostalism (I converted when I married a Pentecostal) and it’s hard after 15 years of not being allowed to think for myself.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Jamie Carter says:

    I had to leave my denomination to find some peace of mind. So I tried methodism. It’s been better. I totally get where you’re coming from – I saw a thing about televangelists, seed faith giving, and healing – it looked a lot like extortion and scams. You’re right to be skeptical, if your church can’t or won’t see that then you might be better off going somewhere else.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. swo8 says:

    God gave you a brain and for good reason. God bless.
    Leslie

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s